IPTC (a standard set by the International Press Telecommunications Council) is one method of photo organization. This is the closest thing we have to a standard for embedding information in digital photographs. You know, all that stuff people write on the backs of the paper ones, or anything else you’d like to add.
What this means in practical terms is that if you enter the information once, it will carry through to other software. Some other software. IPTC is still not as universal as it might be. We can hope.
For instance, FastStone Viewer, doesn’t use it. Picasa uses it but only on JPG’s. Conversely, any description added to a JPG in Adobe Elements will show up as a caption in Picasa. Adobe Elements will handle other formats but Picasa will not read them. And so on and so forth with other graphics software. Before you get too gung-ho jumping into this great idea, run some tests and make sure it works the way you want it to.
A good question to ask yourself is what do you plan to do with your pictures? That can narrow down your experiments on a long-term filing system. I know it’s tough to have a plan, though, if you don’t know what all your options are and just owning a computer is like running on top of a moving ball.
Passage Express is still, so far, the best thing I know for presenting my genealogy work as it can make a compilation of many kinds of files: graphics, slideshows, audio, text, genealogy charts. So I’m looking at this from the end point backwards. Any number of programs will “organize” my photographs in some manner, but which method is going to get me from folders full of photographs to organized in Passage Express in the shortest line possible?
This is not all my 12,000 photos but since I know that I want to use some photos in both Legacy and Passage Express, using IPTC descriptions on those will save me having to rewrite or copy/paste the descriptions for them twice.
It’s a little messy, though, as it precedes the wanted text with <rdf:li xml:lang=’x-default’> that will have to be deleted on every single one of them. Perhaps the Passage Express engineers would be amenable to repairing that. (Aug 24 update: The <rdf:li xml:lang=’x-default’> preamble only happens in certain instances, not most. I have corresponded with their tech support about this and await further notice.)
(Another way around this is to use Windows File Properties. This is not IPTC though. When you’ve imported your image into Passage Express, open it in ‘Default Application’ (Windows Picture and Fax Viewer probably) right-click and go down to Properties to open the File Properties box and copy and paste the information into ‘Details’ in Passage Express.)
Legacy Family Tree
Legacy will import embedded information from the IPTC Description field for either JPG’s or TIFF’s. But it will only read TIFF’s if they’ve been saved with no compression. If you use LZW it will not recognize them. If you click on a TIFF and get a blank you’ll have to re-save it first making sure to click the No Compression button.
Although I created a whole batch of TIFF’s using No Compression with FastStone Viewer, Legacy does not recognize them. Also, adding IPTC info only works to add to the Description field in individual photo galleries, not in the Picture Center.
Although there are several fields for information in Windows File Properties and in IPTC, the only thing I’ve seen that translates automatically to this other software is the ‘Description’ field.
Embedding comments/descriptions is, of course, not the same thing as a file-naming system. I’m using ‘surname/first-year-#’ for the ancestors. I reached the end of my patience with file-names 50 characters long. Most of that information belongs somewhere else. I know some people put the information into adjoining text files, and I’ve tried that too.
Windows File Properties
I’ve added information to Windows File Properties in XP just to see how that would work out by comparison. The results would be fine as far as indexing and searching and it’s simple. But the information doesn’t carry through to anywhere else. As I said, it would have to be copied and pasted.
Maybe not a bad trade-off for what it’s good for. As long as you intend to use a Windows operating system forevermore, it would be an OK investment. I don’t think any other OS would care about it. The best way to look at it is in the Details view so you can see a thumbnail in the sidebar and all the information laid out across the screen. Information can be sorted according to category by clicking on a header.
I would be interested to hear from someone using Vista whether this has enhanced functionality there.
I like the idea of being able to Search for words or phrases computer-wide and gather up all related-files in a single batch. With Windows indexing turned on this is a simple thing to do. Read Windows File Properties. Searching IPTC info can be done through Adobe, or other software that reads IPTC.
I did find a program called StudioLine that will import or add Windows File Properties as well as any IPTC information. The way the interface is designed makes it extremely easy. However, it only works on JPG’s in the free Basic version. I haven’t tried the Classic ($29) so I can’t say. It’s also a good-looking editor and file browser.
IPTC generally works with JPG’s, TIFF’s and sometimes PSD’s so if you have other formats you’d have to convert them to one of the other formats first. FastStone Viewer has a nifty batch convert mode. I think Adobe will write IPTC info to any format but that doesn’t mean other software will read it.
I’ve also tried BreezeBrowser for adding IPTC information. This works on either single photos or in batch mode. I looked at several others and this is the only one I found that will work with JPG’s, TIFF’s and PSD’s. My Adobe Elements version doesn’t have a batch mode or I would use that instead. No matter which way you slice it, backtracking through hundreds or thousands of photographs to embed information is a lot of work. The saving grace is that fields of information can be added in batch mode, wherever you have common information.
Batch mode would be handy for things like “author”. I have photographs from many different people and have been lately marking them as such. I’d like to make that acknowledgment and also have a record if I ever need to get back to that person for more information. That’s just one example of information to add to photos.
A very simple and useful thing anyone can do is either add Windows File Properties or IPTC info to photos before emailing them. Usually I get a list of comments in email preceding the photos and the photos never arrive in the order the sender thinks they sent them. Once I got a hand-written list to print out and cross-match. Dead people’s names and comments numbered 1-86 and there were 94 photos. J.B., if you’re reading this, I’m still confused.
If I have previously added Windows File Properties on a PSD or TIFF, adding IPTC through Adobe Elements will strip everything out. It will allow me to re-add Comments in Windows File Properties to PSD’s, but not to TIFF’s. Using both on JPG’s seems to be fine.